Engagement Rings
Wedding Rings
Earrings
Bracelets

Perfectly Imperfect. One of a Kind.

Every salt & pepper diamond tells a different story. Hand-selected stones, crafted into one-of-a-kind rings — never replicated, never ordinary.

Shop Salt & Pepper Diamonds

  • Free Shipping

  • Easy 30 Day Returns

  • Manufacturer Warranty

  • Best Price Promise

  • Skin-Friendly

  • Conflict-Free Diamonds

  • Stress-Free Purchase

  • Free Shipping

  • Easy 30 Day Returns

  • Manufacturer Warranty

  • Best Price Promise

  • Skin-Friendly

  • Conflict-Free Diamonds

  • Stress-Free Purchase

  • Free Shipping

  • Easy 30 Day Returns

  • Manufacturer Warranty

What Our Customers Say

  • 5-Star Diamond and Service ✨

    Great experience with Northfire Jewelry. The salt and pepper diamond I bought is high quality and looks amazing. Accurate description, professional service, and a very smooth transaction. 5 stars!

    Lauren Schneider

    Brick, NJ

  • Impressive Selection and Technical Excellence

    I recently purchased a salt and pepper diamond from Northfire Jewelry and I am very impressed with the quality. As someone who works in the diamond industry, I specifically look for stones with a unique balance of inclusions and character, and this stone delivered exactly that. The 'pepper' distribution is beautiful and the cut maximizes the stone's natural brilliance. The ordering process was smooth and the diamond arrived exactly as described. I’ll definitely be looking at their collection for future pieces.

    Jennifer Peuler

    Ephrata, PA

  • Found the Perfect Galaxy Diamond!

    Absolutely stunning salt and pepper diamond! I’ve been looking for the perfect stone for a while, and Northfire Jewelry has the best selection. The diamond has so much personality and the 'galaxy' effect is even better in person. Great customer service and fast shipping. If you are looking for a unique, high-quality diamond, I highly recommend buying from them!

    Kim Martinez

    Longview, TX
1 3

Got Questions? We Got Answers

What are Salt & Pepper Diamonds?

Salt & pepper diamonds are natural diamonds that contain unique black, white, and grey inclusions. These internal characteristics give each stone its distinctive, one-of-a-kind appearance — no two are ever alike.

Are Salt & Pepper Diamonds Natural?

Yes. Salt & pepper diamonds are 100% natural diamonds formed over millions of years. Their inclusions are a natural part of the stone’s formation and are what make them special.

Why Choose a Salt & Pepper Diamond Over a White Diamond?

Salt & pepper diamonds celebrate character and individuality over perfection. They appeal to those who want something distinctive, expressive, and non-traditional.

Does NFJ offer jewelry insurance?

While NFJ doesn’t offer insurance directly, you can purchase third-party insurance separately if desired. Visit our shipping policy website for more details on jewelry insurance options.

Can I Use a Salt & Pepper Diamond for a Custom Ring?

Yes. All of our diamonds can be used to create a custom engagement ring or piece of jewelry designed specifically around your chosen stone.

What's Northfire Jewelry's return policy like?

Northfire Jewelry offers a 30-day return policy. If you're not completely satisfied with your purchase, you can return it within 30 days for a full refund or an exchange. For more details, please review our full return policy here.

Do You Ship Internationally?

Yes, we ship worldwide. All diamonds are securely packaged and fully insured during transit.